Portrait of Pope Francis
Religious_leader · concept
Wikipedia (opens in new tab)

Pope Francis on Women in the Church

Elevates lay roles no priesthood (strong)

Pope Francis maintains a nuanced position regarding women in the Church, characterized by firm resistance to ordination in the priesthood or diaconate, which he has stated is a closed topic theologically. Despite this, his pontificate has seen a significant advancement of women into high-level administrative and governance roles within the Roman Curia.

He views the Church as fundamentally "female" and has called for a deeper theological reflection on womanhood, criticizing the Church's historical "masculinizing." This push for greater female influence is seen in his actions, such as appointing women to lead Vatican departments and granting them voting rights in the Synod of Bishops, aiming to move them from mere decorative additions to substantial partners in governance.

His reforms, particularly the 2022 reorganization of the Roman Curia, officially separated governance authority from sacramental orders, allowing laypersons, including women, to head dicasteries. This approach underscores his belief that administrative roles do not require ordination, though critics argue that true equality remains blocked by the ban on sacramental ministry.

Actions Taken

  1. Key Vatican Appointments
    Appointed the first woman Prefect of a Vatican dicastery and the first woman President of the Vatican City State's government.
  2. Synod Reform
    Gave women the right to vote in the Synod of Bishops for the first time, with full member status in the 2023 Synod on Synodality.
  3. Ministry Recognition
    Formally recognized lay ministry roles, such as lectors and acolytes, to women through the 2022 Apostolic Constitution Praedicate Evangelium.
  4. Vatican Administration
    Appointed women to significant administrative roles, including undersecretaries in the Secretariat of State and the Dicastery for Promoting Integral Human Development.

Key Quotes

The Church is female... One of our great sins has been masculinizing the Church. And this is not resolved through ministerial means, that's another thing.

Remarks to the International Theological Commission November 30, 2023 — Reiterating the Church's female dimension and past sin of masculinization.

the door is closed” on the issue of women's ordination to the priesthood.

Statement on plane returning from World Youth Day July 1, 2013 — Early in his pontificate, stating a firm boundary on the matter of women priests.

When women are in charge, things go well!

Public address January 1, 2025 — Public praise for women's management capabilities.

Related Positions

  • Roman Curia Reform His 2022 reform was the mechanism used to decouple governance authority from ordination, directly enabling the appointment of women to lead Vatican departments.
  • Synodality His support for broader synods led directly to women gaining voting rights in these key consultative assemblies.
  • Gender-Based Violence He has extended his advocacy for women outside the Church by condemning gender-based violence and economic inequality globally.

Criticism

Pat Brown (Catholic Women's Ordination spokesperson)

Argues that the continued ban on women priests is rooted in misogyny and that Pope Francis has a 'blind spot' regarding giving women 'justice.'

Various observers and activists

Point to his opposition to female ordination as a contradiction to his stated support for greater female involvement, suggesting his approach does not truly challenge the patriarchal structure.

Nuns/Activists (e.g., Gloria Branciani)

Note that despite acknowledging abuse against nuns, the fundamental power structure remains, and women 'don't have voices' without access to ordained roles.

Comparison

Pope Francis's approach to women in the Church contrasts with previous pontificates primarily in the granting of administrative authority and participation in synods, while maintaining continuity on the issue of ordination.

  • Ordination: He firmly holds the line established by St. John Paul II, who in 1994 stated that women's ordination to the priesthood was not up for debate, a stance Francis reiterates.
  • Governance: Francis's reform of the Roman Curia in 2022 formally separated governing power from holy orders, allowing laywomen to lead dicasteries, which represents a significant structural change in administrative roles compared to his predecessors.